Real Leaders vs. Fake Leaders: Unmasking the Authentic Leadership Difference

Discover the telltale signs that distinguish genuine leaders from mere impostors. Are you walking the path of a true leader or merely playing a role?

Share This Article

Men and women asian leaders talking to each other happily

In the realm of leadership, the distinction between real leaders and fake leaders is profound. It goes beyond a mere job title or a facade donned when the spotlight is on.


Authentic leadership is the embodiment of values, a dedication to inspiring others, while fake leadership often amounts to little more than a performance.


In this article, we delve into the critical differences between being a true leader and feigning the role, shedding light on the traits and actions that characterize authentic leadership.

The Leader as an Actor

Acting as a leader can be likened to a carefully rehearsed act, involving a surface-level projection of authority, charisma, or self-assuredness. However, this act lacks the substance and sincerity required for long-term leadership success. Here are some prevalent attributes of those who merely act as leaders:

(1) Ego-Centric: Impersonating leaders tend to place self-interest and personal gain above the collective well-being of their team. Their decisions often revolve around elevating their image or status, rather than serving the best interests of the organization.

(2) Inauthenticity: Such leaders may mimic the behaviors and vernacular of effective leaders, but beneath the façade lies insincerity. Their words and deeds fail to align with their true values and beliefs, corroding trust among team members.

(3) Short-Term Focus: Acting leaders prioritize immediate gains over the long-term, seeking quick victories and instant gratification. This may lead to hasty decisions that undermine the organization’s sustained success.

(4) Micromanagement: Leaders in pretense often grapple with trust issues regarding their team’s capabilities, resulting in excessive micromanagement. This stifles innovation and impedes the growth of their team, fostering disengagement.

(5) Lack of Accountability: When things go awry, acting leaders may shift blame onto others or offer excuses. They evade taking responsibility for their actions and decisions, eroding their credibility.

The Authentic Leader

A group of business people celebrating success together

In contrast, authentic leadership is grounded in genuine values, empathy, and a steadfast commitment to the welfare of the team and the organization. Genuine leaders exhibit qualities and behaviors that set them apart:

(1) Self-Awareness: Authentic leaders possess a profound understanding of themselves, their strengths, and their weaknesses. They embrace their genuine selves, making them more relatable and trustworthy.

(2) Empathy: They actively listen to their team members, demonstrating an understanding of their needs, concerns, and viewpoints. This empathy fosters robust connections and cultivates a positive team culture.

(3) Transparency: Authentic leaders are candid about their intentions, decisions, and the challenges confronting the organization. This transparency establishes trust among team members.

(4) Long-Term Vision: They harbor a compelling and forward-looking vision for the organization, making decisions that serve the long-term success, even if the results are not instantaneous.

(5) Accountability: Authentic leaders hold themselves accountable for their actions and choices, adhering to high standards and expecting the same from their team members.

(6) Adaptability: They willingly embrace learning, growth, and adaptation in the face of change. They foster innovation and cultivate a growth mindset within their teams.


Leadership is not an act to be played but a reflection of one’s authentic self. While temporary success may be achieved by those who act as leaders, genuine leadership demands authenticity, self-awareness, and a dedication to the greater good. To be a leader means embracing vulnerability, acknowledging one’s imperfections, and inspiring others through genuine empathy, trust, and accountability. So, question yourself – are you embodying true leadership, or are you merely a character on a stage? The success of your team and your lasting legacy hinge on your response.

Eager to embark on a leadership journey? Join our Emerging Leadership Development Program. Designed for early-mid career professionals, this program equips you with vital skills in people and functional management. Engage in immersive coaching sessions and assignments to develop your abilities in self, team, and business leadership. Get started on your path to becoming an effective leader today!

If you found this article thought-provoking, you'll want to explore our previous piece on "Generation Leadership Styles." It delves into how different generational perspectives influence leadership approaches and can help you gain valuable insights into the evolving landscape of leadership in today's diverse workforce.

Share This Article

Get Free Consultation